A
Study of Baby and Child Rape
in
South Africa
BTPartners
POBox
891700
Lyndhurst
2106
South
Africa
btpartners@icon.co.za
Table of Contents.
2
Executive
Summary.
3
Aim..
3
Approach.
3
Methodology.
4
Literature
Survey.
4
Structured
Interviews.
4
Statistical
Analysis.
4
Modeling
- Systems Dynamics Modeling.
5
Findings
and Results.
5
Staffing.
6
Sandy
Schwarer
6
Steve
Banhegyi
6
Richard
Lewis.
6
Project
Sponsors.
6
Study Model
6
Professional
Fee.
7
Appendix
I : Sample Study at Daimler Chrysler
8
Source
Business Day 27/02/2002 Page 3.
8
Appendix
II : AIDS in South Africa.
8
Source
– UNISA Bureau of Market Research.
8
Appendix
III : Number of AIDS Deaths in South Africa.
8
Source
– UNISA Bureau of Market Research.
8
Appendix
IV : Reasons for Hight Prevalence of AIDS in South Africa.
8
Source
– UNISA Bureau of Market Research.
9
Appendix
V : Key Uncertainties.
9
Source
– UNISA Bureau of Market Research.
9
Appendix
VI : Impact of HIV / AIDS..
9
Source
– UNISA Bureau of Market Research.
9
Appendix
VII : Results of HIV/AIDS in South Africa.
9
Source
– UNISA Bureau of Market Research.
10
Appendix
VIII : News Story BBC Virgin Myth.
10
Appendix IX : Definitions and core concepts.
10
Appendix
X : Assessment of Key Drivers.
10
Appendix XI : AIDS in South Africa.
11
Appendix XII : Systems Dynamics Approach.
11
The incidence of the rape of babies and children
has been reported widely in the South African press over the years. It
appears some people subscribe to the belief that having sex with a
virgin will cure HIV/AIDS. This is borne out by a study conducted by
the University of South Africa at the Daimler Chrysler plant where 18%
of those surveyed believed that having sex with a virgin would cure
the disease. This is a worrying statistic and demands research to
establish the extent of these belief systems and whether or not these
beliefs are on the increase. The objectives of this proposal are to:
- Conduct
a thorough search on the literature of the beliefs associated with
HIV/AIDS being cured as a result of having sex with a virgin
- Appraise
whether or not there is an increasing acceptance of these beliefs
- Identify
which populations or segments of the population ascribe to these
beliefs
- Highlight
any differences and / or similarities in these belief systems by
demographics, affiliation, education etc..
- Obtain
an understanding of what led to these beliefs becoming an urban
legend or part of the conventional wisdom
- To
interview a sample of individuals who have been successfully
prosecuted for the crime of baby / child rape
- Evaluate
wheter there is an increase in the trend of baby/child rapes and,
if so, in which segments this occurs
The
aim of this project is to produce a report describing the key drivers
for change that might be expected to impact the incidence of baby and
child rape in South Africa over the next decades. The report will
additionally attempt to model and forecast these trends.
This
is intended to provide background material for subsequent work,
communication campaigns and policy development in this area.
The
basic approach will be one of a sophisticated literature review and
analysis. That is, to scan the published body of work, select studies
of sufficient relevance and stature, extract and assess the key
elements, synthesise a description of the current state of the art and
to present the results as a basis for further thinking.
The
litereature review will be complemented by
- Statistical
analysis of available data from Statistics SA and the South
African Police Services
- Qualitative
research including structured interviews
- The
development of a model of the phenomenon that will allow
policymakers to test the efficacy of their interventions.
The
Literature Survey will comprise a meta-analysis of the published body
of work and research related to Baby / Child Rape in South Africa. The
aim of this analysis will be to synthesise a view describing the key
drivers for change that might be expected to affect the incidence of
baby & child rape in South Africa over the next decades.
The Literature survey will be conducted by
reviewing both paper-based and electronic documentation.
The literature survey will be conducted by Sandy
Schwarer
The structured interviews will be undertaken with
a number of target populations namely:
- Those
individuals successfully prosecuted for baby / child rape and who
have been incarcerated. 10 Interviews have been budgeted for this
study.
- A
sample of 10 Sangomas (Witchdoctors) and 10 Inyangas
(Herbalists). A total of 20 Interviews of Sangomans and Inyangas
have been budgeted for in this study.
- A
sample of AIDS patients who are currently undergoing treatment for
AIDS and AIDS related complications in Gauteng Hospitals. A total
of 60 interviews of AIDS patients has been budgeted for here.
- A
sample of 20 healthcare professionals working with AIDS. These
professionals will need to have been involved with AIDS patients
for 5 years or more.
The structured interviews will be undertaken by
Steve Banhegyi and Richard Lewis
Statistical Analysis will be undertaken on the
quantitative data in order to determine whether there is an increase
in the trend of baby/child rapes and, if so, in which segments this
occurs.
The quantitative data will be made available by
Statistics SA and by the South African Police Services who have both
indicated that they will co-operate with this study.
The approach to Statistical Analysis will be to
assemble a time series of incidence of Rape by area and by age and sex
of victim. The resultant data will be input into a Neural Network and
Fuzzy Clustering Algorithm. The result of these analyses is to
identify any underlying clusters, patterns or trends in the data and
to highlight any psychographics of interest.
Statistical Analyses will be undertaken using
DataEngine 3.0 and the Statistica version 6.0 packages. Source data
and the resultant analyses will be placed upon a website and members
of the research community will be encouraged to use this data in their
own analyses.
The Statistical Analyses will be undertaken by
Steve Banhegyi.
Part of this project will require that a Systems
Dynamics model be developed using the Vensim modeling tool. It is
planned that the final presentation will also include a live run of
the model at which time attendees will be able to see the impact and
efficacy of various policy interventions.
System Dynamics is a method for studying the
world around us. The central concept to system dynamics is the
understanding of how all the objects in a system interact with one
another. A system can be anything from a steam engine, to a bank
account, to a rugby team. The objects and people in a system interact
through "feedback" loops, where a change in one variable
affects other variables over time, which in turn affects the original
variable, and so on.
Systems Dynamics attempts to understand the basic
structure of a system, and thus understand the behaviour it can
produce. Many of these systems and problems can be built as models on
a computer. System dynamics takes advantage of the fact that a
computer model can be of much greater complexity and carry out more
simultaneous calculations than can the mental model of the human mind.
The Systems Dynamics approach is not a new one
and has been used with great success in a number of environments and
industries. In this respect, there are a number of references and
examples given. We feel it important to suggest this approach because
the model which emerges from an SD approach is:
·
Much more flexible, reliable and valid than a model
developed using traditional tools such as excel
·
Allows participants in the modeling process to better
understand the variables and system being modeled
·
Allows deep insight into the behaviour or and
interactions between the system components.
The Modeling will be undertaken by Steve
Banhegyi.
The findings and results of this proposal will be
handed over to sponsors and any other interested parties. Each sponsor
will be provided with a printed copy of this study. An additional
electronic version of the study will be made available in Adbobe
Acrobat for download through a website.
Additionally, a final presentation of the
study’s results will be made at a public venue. It will be ensured
that all sponsors will be mentioned during the presentation.
Sandy holds a BA(Hons) in politics(?)
Steve has Consulted since 1983 primarily for
clients in the Financial Services and Public Service area specialising
in Financial Modelling, Simulation, Administration, Marketing and
Forecasting Systems. He has also worked extensively for government and
private clients in Healthcare and Law Enforcement and Public
Utilities. He has lectured in Information Systems at the University of
the Witwatersrand for 4.5 years. In addition, Steve has also lectured
Consumer Behaviour and Statistics. His specialist areas include
Command Control Systems, Knowledge Management and Organisational
Transformation.
Since 1996 Steve has partnered with Martens Thiel
and Partner in Cologne who specialise in the privatisation of public
utilities / municipalities in Germany. Cities consulted to by MTP
include the cities of Wupperthal, Cologne, Bieleveld, Sollingen,
Duisburg and Dortmund. Steve's duties and responsibilities have
included Organisational Design and Restructuring, Privatisation
planning, Scenario planning, negotiation with stakeholders and the
facilitation of seminars.
The following organisations have indicated their
support for the aims and methodology of this proposal:
- CATHCA
– The Catholic Health Care Association
This
study will use the following working model:
Input
data Þ
Trends
& Drivers Þ Outcomes Þ Predictions
& Explorations
Project Component
|
Professional
Fee
|
Literature Survey, Summarisation and
Writeup
|
30000
|
Structured Interviews
|
45000
|
Statistical Analysis
|
25000
|
Report Writing / Presentation including
venue costs
|
20000
|
Expenses
|
|
- Translation
and interpreting fees
|
15000
|
|
30000
|
|
10000
|
|
|
TOTAL
|
R 175,000.00
|
Study done by the University of South Africa at
Daimler Chrysler between May and July of 2001 focused on 498 of 4495
employees. Key points of the study included:
- 18%
of those surveyed believed that having sex with a virgin would
cure the disease
- 8,7%
of Daimler Chrysler’s employees are HIV positive or have full
blown AIDS
- 20%
of those surveyed believed that the disease could be cured via the
use of traditional african medicine
- Few
of those surveyed would change their sexual behaviour despite the
disease
- Respondents
felt that health care professionals had failed in raising
awareness about the disease
- There
appears to be a lack of faith in the efficacy of condoms
One of the highest per capita HIV/AIDS prevalence
and infection rates in the world About 1800 new infections per day An
estimated 4.5 to 6 million South Africans already HIV positive About
290000 people died because of AIDS related diseases during 2000.
This is expected to rise to about 800000+ by 2008
180000 – 220000 in 1999
250000 – 300000 in 2000
340000 - 400000 in 2002
450000 – 500000 in 2004
550000 – 650000 in 2006
700000 – 850000 in 2008
750000 – 850000 in 2010
- Social
and family disruption
- High
mobility and good transport
- High
poverty and low education levels
- High
level of STDs, low status of women
- Low
contraceptive prevalence
- Many
sexual partners
- Culture
and risk behavior
- Fear
of admitting status (denial)
- HIV/AIDS
parameters, progress and epidemiological pattern
- Institutional
capacity to deal with it
- Efficacy
of drugs and vaccines
- Efficacy
of macro-, meso- and micro- responses to HIV/AIDS
- Multipliers
and mediating variables
- Economy,
education, business
·
Demographic – size and structure
- Labour
supply and demand - outsourcing
- Skills
availability and skills formation
- Income
impacts
- Expenditure
and savings patterns
- Health
sector – cost and effort
- Entrepreneurship
Economic structure and capital intensification
- Government
expenditure foci
- Delivery
modes and affordability (economy of scale effects)
- Factor
flight and lower GDP per capita
- Development
and poverty
- Priorities
of people (medicines vs. education)
- Formal
sector behavior
- Four
to eight million less people by 2010
- Loss
of 400000 highly skilled people and entrepreneurs
- Strong
growth in unemployment and poverty
- Decline
in business confidence
- Impact
on economic growth and development
- Economic
development and instability
- Productivity
and production
A series of recent baby rapes has
stunned South Africans and left many questioning the direction its
society is going.
The report highlighted the belief
among many perpetrators that having sex with virgins can cure Aids, in
a country which has the highest number of sufferers of the disease in
the world.
The study was highly critical of the
South African Government's attitude towards HIV and Aids, which, it
said, was a major cause of its failure to make anti-retroviral drugs
widely available to rape victims.
It said regulations surrounding the
testing of suspected rapists for HIV for use as evidence in court were
"confused" and needed clarifying.
The report also said treating infant
victims of sex crimes was not enough in itself.
"Concerted action is needed to
halt this abhorrent crime," it said.
Source http://news.bbc.co.uk/hi/english/world/africa/newsid_1781000/1781032.stm
Many
studies have used similar words to describe the research process, but
there is a wide variation in how they are interpreted. For the
purposes of this report we use the following:
- Input
data: Observations, raw data, empirical evidence, sources etc.
that are then analysed / synthesised to produce trends. An example
of input data would be mean summer temperatures for the last 50
years.
- Trends:
Trajectories, extrapolations, projections, and possibly even
predictions, which are continuous and (usually) monotonic. An
example trend would be ‘The increasing proportion of the
World’s population living in developing countries’.
- Drivers:
Used here to identify the meta factors or groups of trends
that share a common theme. An example would be ‘Demographics’.
- ‘Wild
cards’: (Relatively) abrupt changes of particular significance,
these include potential catastrophes and other high-impact,
low-probability events, sometimes termed ‘wildcards’. An
example would be the Chernobyl accident.
- Outcomes:
A generic term for predictions, future ‘worlds’ and
scenarios. These usually draw on a number of trends and events.
Previous
studies have identified a number of
trends that are going to shape the future of HIV/AIDS
Epidemiology in South Africa. There is reasonable – albeit not
universal – agreement in the shape and direction of these trends.
Analysis and cross-correlation showed that the trends could be grouped
thematically into the following minimum set of key drivers:
- Demographics
- Environmental
Change
- Economics
- Science
and Technology.
- National
and International Governance.
- Perceptions,
Beliefs, Values and Attitudes.
Based on statistics
presented by the UN at the end of 1999, 4,200,000 Adults and children
were infected by HIV in South Africa of whom 4,100,000 were Adults
aged 15-49. The Adult infection rate (%) was 19.94%. Of the total
number of adults infected, 2,300,000 were women and approximately
95,000 were children. It is extimated that 250,000 people died in
South Africa from AIDS in 1999.
Source:
United Nations Epidemiological Fact Sheets on HIV/AIDS and
sexually transmitted infections
The following approach is used in the modeling
task:
1.
Task Definition –
A Broad Description of the modeling task and its major components,
variables and subsystems
2.
Component Behavious
Definition – This identifies the key variables in the system and
plots their behaviour over time
3.
Focus – this will
involve the creation of a focusing statement for the project
4.
Structure identification
& Modeling – this involves a deep study and basic systems
modeling of the system under study. When the model starts to behave
like the system under study, we may then assume that our model has
become more reliable and more valid.
5.
Intervention planning
– Once the model has been developed (step 6) we may then start to
simulate variuous policy decisions using the model
Appendix XIII – Nelspruit Child Rape Epidemic
It is reported that out of 215 cases of rape
heard in the Nelspruit regional court in 2001, only 11 convictions
were secured by the state. It is further reported that the Department
of Social Welfare cannot cope with the rising tide of child rapes and
increasing poverty in general.
Nelspruit Child Rape Epidemic
|
Age (years)
|
No
of Rapes (2001)
|
Jan
and Feb (2002)
|
<5
|
45
|
12
|
6-10
|
70
|
8
|
11-15
|
104
|
18
|
16-18
|
66
|
10
|
19-30
|
102
|
10
|
31-40
|
54
|
10
|
>41
|
36
|
1
|
Total
|
477
|
69
|
Given the thesis that the incidence of rapes are
generally eveny distributed over time, it appears that in 2002 there
will be a significantly grater incidence of rape than in 2001.
Source Greater Rape Intervention Project
(GRIP), Financial Mail March 8th, 2002 Page 26
|